Why Your Brand Isn’t Connecting with Your Audience. Understanding how to create a brand that connects.
- Marla Jeken
- Sep 28, 2024
- 5 min read
Updated: Oct 30, 2024

You’ve launched your business, worked hard on your branding, and put yourself out there—but something isn’t quite right. Despite your best efforts, your audience isn’t connecting with your brand, and your engagement numbers are low.
Why is my brand not resonating with customers?
You're not alone. Many startups face this challenge early on, often without knowing why. Common branding mistakes for startups can hinder growth.
Branding isn’t just about having a nice logo or a snappy slogan—it’s about creating a connection with your audience. And when that connection isn’t happening, it’s usually due to a few common branding mistakes that can easily be fixed.
In this post, we’re going to explore why your brand might not be resonating with your audience and how to improve brand engagement.
1. You Don’t Know Your Audience Well Enough
One of the most common reasons brands fail to connect is that they don’t fully understand who they’re speaking to. If you aren’t crystal clear on who your ideal audience is, it’s going to be nearly impossible to create a brand that resonates with them.
Think of it like this: If you’re speaking to everyone, you’re really speaking to no one. A broad, generic message doesn’t strike a chord with anyone in particular, making your brand forgettable.
Common Mistakes:
You haven’t done enough research into your target audience’s needs, interests, and behaviors.
You’re trying to appeal to too many different types of people at once.
Your messaging is too vague or too focused on what you think is important, rather than what your audience cares about.
Solution: Start by getting to know your audience inside and out. This means researching not just their demographics (age, location, etc.), but their psychographics—the deeper stuff like their motivations, pain points, and goals.
Ask yourself: What keeps them up at night? What are they looking for that your brand can solve?
Tools like Google Trends and SurveyMonkey can provide invaluable insights. Once you have a solid understanding of your ideal client, you can tailor your messaging and branding to speak directly to them.
2. Your Messaging Isn’t Clear or Consistent
Your brand message is the story you’re telling the world. If that story is unclear or inconsistent, people won’t stick around to figure it out. They’ll just move on to a brand that’s easier to understand.
If your brand is all over the place—one day playful, the next day serious—your audience won’t know what to expect. A lack of consistency creates confusion, and confused customers rarely turn into loyal ones.
Common Mistakes:
Your brand tone and voice change depending on the platform or day of the week.
Your messaging doesn’t clearly explain what you offer or how it benefits your audience.
You’re using industry jargon that your audience doesn’t understand.
Solution: Create a brand style guide to help keep your messaging on track. This should outline your brand’s voice (how you sound), tone (the emotional quality), and key messaging points.
Make sure your audience understands:
Who you are (your brand personality),
What you do (your product or service),
Why it matters to them (how it solves their problems).
When your message is clear, your audience knows exactly what they’re getting from your brand—and more importantly, why they should care.
3. Your Visual Identity Is Inconsistent or Outdated
In today’s digital world, your visual identity is often the first impression your audience has of your brand. If your visuals don’t align with your brand message or feel outdated, they could be turning potential customers away.
Consistency is key when it comes to your visual identity. If your colors, fonts, and imagery change from platform to platform, or from product to product, your audience won’t recognize you. And if they don’t recognize you, they won’t build the connection you need for long-term loyalty.
Common Mistakes:
You’re using different fonts, colors, and logos across platforms, leading to a disjointed look.
Your visuals don’t reflect your brand’s personality or values.
Your design is outdated or doesn’t match current trends.
Solution: Audit your current brand visuals. Are they cohesive? Do they reflect your brand’s core values? If not, it might be time for a brand refresh.
Choose a color palette, fonts, and logo that reflect your brand’s identity and stick with them across all platforms. Consistency in your visuals will build trust and recognition over time.
4. You’re Focused on Features, Not Benefits
Another reason your brand may not be connecting with your audience is that you’re focusing too much on what your product or service does, rather than why it matters to them.
People don’t just buy products—they buy solutions to their problems. If your branding is all about the features of your product or service, but doesn’t explain how it will improve your audience’s life, you’re missing the mark.
Common Mistakes:
You’re highlighting features like price or specifications, but not explaining the value those features provide.
Your messaging doesn’t make it clear how your product will solve your audience’s pain points.
Solution: Shift your focus from features to benefits. Instead of telling your audience what your product does, show them how it will solve their problems or improve their lives.
For example, instead of saying “Our software has 10 customizable features,” say, “Our software makes your life easier by saving you time and helping you stay organized.”
5. You’re Not Engaging with Your Audience
Branding isn’t a one-way street. If you’re just putting content out into the world and hoping people will engage with it, you’re missing a critical part of building a brand connection—engagement.
People want to feel seen and heard. If you’re not responding to comments, questions, or messages, your audience may feel disconnected from your brand.
Solution: Start treating your audience like a community, not just customers. Ask them questions, respond to their comments, and show genuine interest in their feedback.
6. You Haven’t Told Your Brand Story
People love stories. They want to know why you started your business, what challenges you’ve overcome, and what drives you to do what you do. If your branding doesn’t include a compelling narrative, you’re missing out on a powerful way to connect with your audience on an emotional level.
Solution: Weave your brand story into your messaging. Tell your audience why you started your business, what makes you passionate about it, and how you’re committed to helping them. Learn more about how to craft a compelling brand story.
Final Thoughts: Refining Your Brand Identity to Build Connections
At the end of the day, building a strong brand connection takes time, effort, and a deep understanding of your audience. If your brand isn’t resonating with people, it’s often due to a disconnect between what you’re offering and what they truly need.
By taking a step back and refining your brand’s messaging, visual identity, and engagement strategies, you can create a brand that not only stands out but also builds lasting relationships with your audience.
Need additional help?
Inconsistent messaging and visuals make it hard for customers to understand who you are. Let me help you fix that with designs that engage and convert.
Comments